The Secretary of State at the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee

screenshot-2026-11-19-125650.png
Copyright: parliament.tv

Yesterday, the Secretary of State Sir Chris Bryant, along with the Northern Ireland Office (NIO) Parliamentary Under-Secretaries of State and departmental officials, appeared before the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee at Westminster. This was the Secretary of State’s first appearance before the Committee, following his appointment on 20 July. There was a wide-ranging discussion about issues including legacy, Drumcree, the Windsor Framework and the upcoming UK-EU summit. In this article we focus on what was said about the Budget discussions and institutional reform.

“There is no more money”

Opening the session, the Committee chair asked for an update on the Secretary of State’s engagement with the Executive about the budget. He responded that the situation was in “stasis”. The NIO have offered £1.5bn extra over three years, which the Secretary of State said is a “full and final offer”. This includes the condition to raise £100m extra revenue in 2027-28, and £200m extra in 2028-29. This was framed as “self-help” to stabilise finances this year and next year.

He expressed a frustration with the Executive: claiming that ministers ask for different amounts of funding “every week” and noted the tense relationships between the parties.

The Secretary of State argued that the priority should be ensuring Northern Ireland receives fair funding – independently determined to be 124% of spending per head in England. The UK Government’s funding of the Executive meets that level, and, along with the £1.5bn extra and Barnett consequentials from the UK Budget, Northern Ireland would be funded at 126% over the Spending Review period. He also disagreed that Northern Ireland should be funded ‘above need’ in a similar way to Scotland and Wales, which would mean the Executive received £3bn or £1bn more respectively. “Northern Ireland is getting fair funding”, he said, and added that the various additional financial packages NI has received over the last decade would have given Wales an extra £26bn.

Despite the higher spending per head of the population, the Secretary of State pointed out the worse outcomes in health, justice and education in Northern Ireland compared to England. He added that pay awards are “not unpredictable expenditure”, and ministers should have prepared for this earlier in the year, potentially through revenue raising.

He said that NIO officials have not yet started planning for passing a budget over the head of the Executive, but the Secretary of State warned of a “public sector crisis” looming in early 2027 which may force them to intervene. He warned that without an agreed budget this year, the Executive would be unable to spend anything next year as under current arrangements, ministers are only permitted to spend a proportion of the previous year’s settlement. The NI Civil Service has done a “Red Amber Green” plan for potential budget cuts this year, which has not yet been shared with the NIO.

A number of Committee members, as well as the NIO representatives, focused on the impact of the budget impasse on the Voluntary and Community Sector and businesses. Their ability to plan, employ staff and work with communities is limited by financial uncertainty. Under-Secretary of State Ruth Anderson praised community leaders for stepping up in the absence of political leadership.  According to Under-Secretary of State Sarah Owen, businesses have got used to “getting around” the political instability and lack of decision-making in Stormont.

Without an agreed budget, the Executive cannot access the Barnett money provided by the £100 household energy support announced by the Chancellor in last month’s UK Budget. However, the Secretary of State raised the removal of tariffs on home heating oil as something that will benefit Northern Ireland more than the rest of the UK due to the higher use here.

The Secretary of State discussed the many strong sectors in Northern Ireland’s economy – including cyber-security, creative and defence. There is potential in these areas which cannot be capitalised on without an agreed financial settlement. The opportunities available through dual market access and consistently strong growth compared to the rest of the UK are there to be grabbed by leaders here.

“Radical surgery” to the institutions

The Secretary of State made clear that he has been considering potential reforms to the Stormont institutions and has been working with the main parties in the Assembly to discuss possible elements of a reform package.

His thinking is clearly linked to the current budget stand-off. It is “abnormal”, he said, not to have “collective financial responsibility” in the Executive, pointing to structural and cultural challenges in our system. The budget crisis should be driving thinking about whether the structures of government here are serving the people. He believes that “radical surgery” is needed before the 30th anniversary of the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement.

In the meantime, he is also interested in “keyhole surgery” before the May 2027 election that reduces the risk of collapse or of an Executive not being formed. He suggested that changing the election of the Speaker to a weighted majority system and reforms to the single-party veto (where one of the top two parties can refuse to nominate ministers and hold up the formation of the Assembly and Executive) could make a difference.

Pivotal’s analysis

A negotiated outcome to the budget impasse looks increasingly unlikely given the entrenched positions of the Executive and UK Government. At the same time there is a growing urgency for a budget to be set, given the interim funding arrangements will reach their 95% limit early in the new year, together with the need to make public sector pay awards. Relations between the Executive parties have deteriorated significantly since Drumcree, and the Secretary of State is evidently frustrated by the lack of progress.

The debate about fair funding is central to this dispute. Whether Northern Ireland should be funded to relative need (124% of England) or funded in a similar way to Scotland and Wales has been at the core of the dispute in private negotiations and public media appearances. The Secretary of State has been clear in his view that NI is funded at need (and would be above need with the additional £525m per year plus Barnett), but the the parties within the Executive are united in advocating for substantially more funding than is currently on the table. The NIO say that there is no more money on offer and the Executive says it needs up to £1.6bn more this year.

A budget for 2026-27 has to be set, and an outcome that is growing more likely is that the Secretary of State is forced to pass a budget for this year over the heads of the Executive. This would be a significant failure of devolution and leadership on both sides. It would be strongly opposed by the Executive, given the impacts on public spending and services, and would come at a time when the institutions are already extremely fragile. The Secretary of State did not rule out taking additional powers to raise more revenue in Northern Ireland.

On Stormont reform, the Secretary of State is clearly thinking about finding a package of measures to be implemented in the coming months, ahead of the Assembly election. His priorities appear to be preventing collapse or stalled formation, along with encouraging greater fiscal responsibility. A reform package needs to improve the stability of the institutions and enable more effective good government here. But the Secretary of State should be prepared for opposition from some parties in the Assembly. Any reforms need to carry the confidence of MLAs in the chamber, and the wider public in Northern Ireland.

You can watch the full session of the Committee here.